Q:
In a non-IPO cycle, my house is ready to go in September or October. Should I hold for spring?
No — go. The fall market is nearly as competitive as spring (69% of houses selling over list in Sep–Oct versus 70% at the May peak, and only about 2.2% below spring on $/sqft). Holding a September-ready house until March 2027 means five or six months of carrying costs — mortgage, taxes, and insurance — to capture a normal-year escalator of about +3.9%. On a $2M house that is roughly $78K of expected appreciation against $50–70K of carrying and life on hold. In a normal year, close to a wash.
Q:
And in an unlock year?
The math flips if there really is a post-lockup cash surge. The fall-to-next-spring escalator jumps from +3.9% to
+14.4% (on a $/sqft basis)
— which should make up for any carrying costs. Sellers who held from fall 2012 to spring 2013 were paid handsomely for waiting, but the same was not the case for fall 2018 and spring 2019.
Q:
If I wait in the fall for the spring in an IPO cycle, will there be a payoff?
Waiting to time the market is always fraught — unless it’s someone ready to sell in August waiting until September, or December waiting until January. It is a bet, not a coupon. Sellers who held from spring to fall 2022 gave back roughly 18% when rates broke the market, and the 2019 sellers who waited on the “IPO tsunami” got nothing. Now, if you are improving your home in the meantime — updating finishes in kitchens and/or bathrooms, or doing repair work so that the investments to a home really show — then there’s a different narrative to consider.
Q:
What about this AI cycle specifically?
This IPO go-around isn’t necessarily seasonal but is shaping up (from current indications) to approximate San Francisco’s normal seasonality. The S-1 and actual IPO dates make the difference. If an OpenAI or Anthropic S-1 drops in October, history says the market re-rates that week, and a house on the market that fall just catches the surge without waiting for spring at all. Meanwhile the anticipatory market surge is already here. Holding out for more is a different risk profile than holding in a normal market.
Q:
Bottom line?
Our advice is still to aim for the
Labor Day–early October window;
if we miss it, we are usually better off holding for spring anyway. But this fall may see many more buyers clamoring to compete and buy now, out of fears of being priced out in Q1/Q2 2027. That said, if more sellers choose to sell next cycle, there may well be more inventory and more seller competition.